Lost because I pointed out we are heading towards a war with Iran?
A war Iran seems to want?
A war not of the proxy variety since Iran has used 100's of billions given to it by the creepy Kenyan to prop up groups like Houthis, Hezbollah and Hamas.
A war Israel is building up to but I'm the lost cause.
Ben has been on a different path than you and has arrived at a different conclusion. I know because I walked his path too.
Iran was selected years ago as the strike to the match to begin WWW3.
To explain why this is so, weтАЩd have to go back to the Obama years. ItтАЩs a lot to unpack.
People in varying stages of awakening have different information, and theyтАЩve walked different paths depending on when they woke up, what they read and who they follow.
It is you who are uneducated in various points on the timeline, not Ben.
You aren't up on the latest conditions in Iran. IDF bombed the bejesus out of Iran's infrastructure. Latest: enough electricity for either heat or lights, not both. They chose heat. Iran is in shambles and struggling. Has anybody heard a peep out of them lately? If would be on CNN (cyber news network). ONN? (Online News Network) (We need a damn acronym!)
My assessment is that the world should assume that the only groups that want war are Israel, the neocons, NATO, those that embrace the 2030 Agenda, and the Globalists. Did I leave anyone out?
NOTE: CTP-ISW will produce the update Monday through Friday beginning February 20, 2025, due to the decrease in military activity in the Gaza Strip and Lebanon and the defeats of Hamas and Hezbollah. We will resume daily, seven-day coverage if circumstances change. CTP-ISW will notify our readers when we resume seven-day coverage. CTP-ISW will continue to produce daily Syria maps. We will publish weekend Syria maps on Mondays. We will cover and assess Axis of Resistance activities in the Palestinian territories and Lebanon at a less granular level moving forward. We will continue to publish analysis on other key US interests in the region, such as the defeat of ISIS and Syrian stability. We will also continue to adjust our Middle Eastern coverage and make those adjustments clear in response to regional dynamics and priorities, just as we did immediately after Hamas' October 7 attack into Israel and the fall of the Assad Regime.
Key Takeaways:
Iranian Rhetoric: Brigadier General Ebrahim JabbariтАФadviser to the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) commanderтАФthreatened to attack "all [US] bases and ships in the region" during a speech at the Great Prophet 19 military exercise on February 20.
Hayat Tahrir al Sham and Syrian Democratic Forces Negotiations: Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) commander Mazloum Abdi said that he and Syrian Interim President Ahmed al Shara agreed on тАЬgeneral principlesтАЭ but still disagree on тАЬpractical details,тАЭ which likely refers to the integration of the SDF into the Syrian army.
Syrian Constitution: The Syrian Preparatory Committee continued тАЬdialogue sessionsтАЭ for Raqqa, Hasakah, and Rif Dimashq provinces in Damascus on February 21.
Iraqi Politics: The United States reportedly threatened to sanction the Iraqi federal government if it prevents the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) from resuming oil exports.
Syria
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) commander Mazloum Abdi said that he and Syrian Interim President Ahmed al Shara agreed on тАЬgeneral principlesтАЭ but still disagreed on тАЬpractical details,тАЭ which likely refers to the integration of the SDF into the Syrian army.[1] Abdi told The Guardian on February 21 that he and Shara agreed to keep Syria unified during the leadersтАЩ last meeting in early January.[2] Abdi said that he and Shara still disagree on the тАЬpractical details,тАЭ including тАЬthe tools for us to work togetherтАЭ and the тАЬtimeline.тАЭ[3] Abdi is likely referring to the specific mechanisms for SDF integration into the Syrian army. An SDF commander said on February 18 that the SDF and the governing body in northeast Syria agreed to merge their forces into the Syrian Defense Ministry.[4] Abdi has not yet publicly confirmed such an agreement. AbdiтАЩs demand that the SDF integrate as a тАЬblocтАЭ was one of the main sticking points of negotiations in the past two months, and it is unclear if either side has moderated their demands on this issue. Abdi also told The Guardian that the тАЬTurkish interventionтАЭ was hurting negotiations.[5] CTP-ISW has previously noted that Abdi is unlikely to give up the SDFтАШs ability to defend Kurdish areas against active attacks by Turkey and the Turkish-backed Syrian National Army (SNA).[6]
Turkish aircraft struck the SDF along the eastern bank of the Euphrates River on February 21. Turkish aircraft struck SDF positions east of Jarabulus.[7] Turkey has repeatedly struck SDF positions across the Euphrates River from Jarabulus since February 12.[8]
Turkey continued to strike SDF positions near Qara Qozak Bridge on February 21. Turkish aircraft struck several SDF positions near Sarrin, likely to isolate SDF units at the bridgehead west of the Qara Qozak Bridge.[9]
Anti-SDF media claimed that Turkish drones struck an SDF checkpoint near al Kasrat, south of Raqqa, on February 21.[10]
The Turkish Defense Ministry announced on February 21 that it killed 8 тАЬPKKтАЭ fighters in northwestern Syria.[11] Turkey routinely conducts strikes targeting the "PKKтАЭ in northern Iraq and Syria, but it commonly conflates the PKK and the SDF.
Yes, they fight back, sometimes effectively. As when they crushed the Israeli invasion of Lebanon a generation ago. What's happening this time? There's a news blackout, so I imagine the Israeli invasion has stalled out.
In Iraq, Iranian missiles destroyed various nests of anti-Iranian terrorists.
Another excellent essay by Mr. Kunstler this week which cites names of people and entities and money.
I like it, though I have lamented, and continue to lament, the lack of objectivity and facts regarding Palestine in CFN essays. Just think, if Mr. Kunstler lifted the carpet and shone his (still, at his age) formidable journalistic spotlight on the crimes of the Israeli state against Palestinians, and even the several ISRAELIS, military and civilian, which the IDF deliberately killed on OCT 07, to ensure they were not captured by Hamas. I repeat my request for JHK to host Max Blumenthal on a Kunstlercast.
I did not plan to bring the topic up, since EPA is not related to Palestine.
However, since Ben is going to loudly bray about the splinter in Iran's eye, vs the LOG in Israel's, I want to share a real story that the US media, mainstream and alternative, has quietly not reported.
All you CFNers can bet your a$$ that if two Jews or Israelis were gunned down in the US, Drudge and MSN, etc, would be all over it. Isn't that right?
Well, two Israelis were WERE gunned down, in Miami, on Feb 16, according to The Guardian (w..theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/17/miami-shooting-israeli-men). Seventeen shots fired at them. The Israelis survived! They took to Facebook to whine about anti-Semitism.
Yet I heard or read nothing, Why? Because the alleged perpetrator, one Mordechai Brafman, 27, is Jewish.
While in custody, Brafman spontaneously told detectives that while he was driving his truck, тАЬhe saw two Palestinians and shot and killed bothтАЭ, arrest documents said.
A lot of people (correctly) point out media bias concerning crime-non-white defendants' race or ethnicity is painted out. Even though statistically black-on-white crime is far more common than white-on-black, wee you know.
That's how it is with the Middle East. Israel is perfect, even as Israelis slaughter tens of thousands of Palestinians, and displace millions, but Iran is the aggressor and threat to peace. according to the media and some here.
Nope they are fighting a war which includes killing people even sometimes people that should not have died but that is the problem with fighting wars good people die along with the badies.
That is how wars are fought or are you just stupid?
To my knowledge Israelis are not kidnapping and then strangling babies.
Nor are they having parties while returning dead babies.
"To my knowledge Israelis are not kidnapping and then strangling babies." ~ Ben
Israelis don't have to if they're bombing and shooting them.
"Nor are they having parties while returning dead babies." ~ Ben
Israel's 'party' is in their apparently much higher baby-kill ratio and big bags of chips on the tax-pimped dime from Uncle Sam.
See what I mean? It's in that style of Israel-Palestine tit-for-tat without end.
But Palestine has a better position and standing, despite the Israel Lobby, its media and other captured US institutions, and perhaps as comments, such as your ill-conceived ones here, would seem to suggest.
Maybe keep your eyes on March 4th., when the parasite State politicians-- maybe cut from a similar cloth to the ones responsible for creating Israel in the first place-- are supposed to meet somewhere nearby (Qatar?) to discuss this catastrophic issue that shouldn't have started in the first place, eighty years ago.
Israel, as a manufactured State construct, is in the wrong neighborhood. We'll see what comes out of that March 4rth. meeting and what they do with the squat that is Israel.
Name a country in the middle east not carved out with little regard for the crazy tribal morons that live there.
Hint look for the straight lines.
I will wait.
Jews are as middle eastern as anything living there today including the Egyptians, Syrians and Jordanians that now call themselves Palestinians as fake and made up a group of people as any other group calling the ME home.
We got another Hamas lover in the group, do we?
While we are on subject of don't belong there is not a Muslim in North America, South America and Europe that belongs, they should all kick rocks back on over to the sand box!
Or does that only apply to dirty JooOOOooooos in the middle east?
Israel has existed in the middle east for thousands of years much longer than Islam and its history is rich with people kicking sand in their faces and eventually losing.
No difference here they are just too damn stubborn.
Just a reminder, Ben, that I'm an anarchist. I can't stress that enough.
So the State, such as the State of Israel, is illegitimate-- right off the bat. So any argument for it is pretty much irrelevant. And let's not conflate it with any more 'Israels' than we need to.
If you/we want Israel to be another kind of Israel, a Stateless one, an organic/grassroots, historically-/religiously-appropriate one, say, and something that's not crutched-- 'USAided'-- by coerced tax hostages of another State, or States, and their MICs, oceans away, then we might be onto something. The Palestinians, etc., might even agree.
As for the Middle East and its current status, well, let's just say it's gotten an unfair shake (sheik?) such as by your ostensible state's illegal war in Iraq for but one example, to say nothing of all its other excursions/incursions in and around the area. And it's a lot easier to talk big when one is on the other side of the business end of a gun.
You keep trashing the people in the general area but seem rather blinkered when it comes to your own State's transgressions, at least in that context.
There are plenty of Jews happily and peacefully living their lives around the world like the rest of us...
They need Israel and special treatment like they need a hole in the head.
I don't know about the story, nor do I care one way or the other but if he walked up and killed people without cause then he will have a trial and go to jail.
No different that anyone else in 'Murica except all the illegal aliens committing crimes and just being deported.
After 75 years they got squatters rights but you should go back to Europe and give your property to the nearest Indian tribe in Canada you are after all nothing but a dirty squatter on stolen Indian land.
Canada, it's history, and I and my family and our history are very different from, and irrelevant to, the Israel-Palestine issue we're discussing.
Again, if those Statists and Zionists setting up Israel in 1948 knew then of the problems or potential problems with the area, whether historically or at the time, they were abjectly irresponsible, to put it mildly perhaps.
Even the commentariat over at JHK's old homesite were expressing concern about the unusual increase in immigration into the US during the past four years or so. Getting them back out was part of Trump's election platform. So why would or should the Palestinians feel much different about 1948, onward?
Anyway, and as I've also mentioned, the Israel-Palestine issue appears as a bit of a distraction from America's (et al's) possible energy interests in the region. In that sense, it appears that Israel is being used as a combination panopticon and base-station/foothold. I've already previously posted a link or two on the energy reserves off the coast of Gaza and in and around the area.
Wars are often, if not always, fundamentally about land and resources.
Do we really think that China is just going to kowtow to USA demands? Maybe a while ago, but thanks to BidenтАЩs Mob, primarily, China does not fear us at all anymore.
No war is "good." I would argue that some war is "necessary." We here in America have an enormous military sized group of people invading our borders. A necessary war would be to eliminate all of these people and send them packing, in defense of our homes and culture. An unnecessary war is like the one in Afghanistan. I don't give a fuck about Afghanistan, Iraq, Gaza, Iran, Yemen, Syria, Germany, Korea, and just about every other nation our army has planted itself.
The only time war is necessary is when it involves protecting and defending ourselves from an aggressive enemy. Most of the time, if not all of the time, the USA seems to be the aggressor.
Would you rather try to stop the constant incursions of other world powers at the border? Or over there? Biden did neither one and we are where we are now. The organization of the millions of illegal immigrants has just started. I hope Trump can send them home without much bloodshed. The Dems just about destroyed American autonomy.
Yes, there is a good war. A Cold War where blustering and bullshit on both sides cancel each other out. Would there ever be hot war if the politicians were silenced?
Generally when a country is drowning in economic stagnation and political angst, the answer is always a good war.
Yes, we are on that course you can see it building.
Target Iran or North Korea or even both.
It won't be China or Russia not, yet they are down the road we need to get some more drone weapons systems online.
Just head on over to MSN and look at all the war footing preparation.
Yes! More war! Bomb the shit out of women and children half a world away!
Ben's a lost cause.
Lost because I pointed out we are heading towards a war with Iran?
A war Iran seems to want?
A war not of the proxy variety since Iran has used 100's of billions given to it by the creepy Kenyan to prop up groups like Houthis, Hezbollah and Hamas.
A war Israel is building up to but I'm the lost cause.
/rolls eyes
Iran wants a war? My God, but you are unhinged.
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95744459
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95773959
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95776810
You don't pay attention, do you?
Tell us, Ben. How is Iran threatening the USA?
Wander on over to MSN and find out.
Ben has been on a different path than you and has arrived at a different conclusion. I know because I walked his path too.
Iran was selected years ago as the strike to the match to begin WWW3.
To explain why this is so, weтАЩd have to go back to the Obama years. ItтАЩs a lot to unpack.
People in varying stages of awakening have different information, and theyтАЩve walked different paths depending on when they woke up, what they read and who they follow.
It is you who are uneducated in various points on the timeline, not Ben.
You get all that from me asking a simple question?
I mean: How on earth can I get better educated if I don't ask questions of those who see things differently than do I?
You aren't up on the latest conditions in Iran. IDF bombed the bejesus out of Iran's infrastructure. Latest: enough electricity for either heat or lights, not both. They chose heat. Iran is in shambles and struggling. Has anybody heard a peep out of them lately? If would be on CNN (cyber news network). ONN? (Online News Network) (We need a damn acronym!)
The following substantiates your claim as well:
Why the Fall of Syria Checkmates Russia & Iran
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oytfhLUy0Fg
... so, what is the objective assessment?
My assessment is that the world should assume that the only groups that want war are Israel, the neocons, NATO, those that embrace the 2030 Agenda, and the Globalists. Did I leave anyone out?
The ayatollahs are selling it as a form of тАЬsufferingтАЭ for Allah? Purely human power complex.
Iran Update, February 21, 2025
NOTE: CTP-ISW will produce the update Monday through Friday beginning February 20, 2025, due to the decrease in military activity in the Gaza Strip and Lebanon and the defeats of Hamas and Hezbollah. We will resume daily, seven-day coverage if circumstances change. CTP-ISW will notify our readers when we resume seven-day coverage. CTP-ISW will continue to produce daily Syria maps. We will publish weekend Syria maps on Mondays. We will cover and assess Axis of Resistance activities in the Palestinian territories and Lebanon at a less granular level moving forward. We will continue to publish analysis on other key US interests in the region, such as the defeat of ISIS and Syrian stability. We will also continue to adjust our Middle Eastern coverage and make those adjustments clear in response to regional dynamics and priorities, just as we did immediately after Hamas' October 7 attack into Israel and the fall of the Assad Regime.
Key Takeaways:
Iranian Rhetoric: Brigadier General Ebrahim JabbariтАФadviser to the Islamic Revolutionary Guards Corps (IRGC) commanderтАФthreatened to attack "all [US] bases and ships in the region" during a speech at the Great Prophet 19 military exercise on February 20.
Hayat Tahrir al Sham and Syrian Democratic Forces Negotiations: Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) commander Mazloum Abdi said that he and Syrian Interim President Ahmed al Shara agreed on тАЬgeneral principlesтАЭ but still disagree on тАЬpractical details,тАЭ which likely refers to the integration of the SDF into the Syrian army.
Syrian Constitution: The Syrian Preparatory Committee continued тАЬdialogue sessionsтАЭ for Raqqa, Hasakah, and Rif Dimashq provinces in Damascus on February 21.
Iraqi Politics: The United States reportedly threatened to sanction the Iraqi federal government if it prevents the Kurdistan Regional Government (KRG) from resuming oil exports.
Syria
Syrian Democratic Forces (SDF) commander Mazloum Abdi said that he and Syrian Interim President Ahmed al Shara agreed on тАЬgeneral principlesтАЭ but still disagreed on тАЬpractical details,тАЭ which likely refers to the integration of the SDF into the Syrian army.[1] Abdi told The Guardian on February 21 that he and Shara agreed to keep Syria unified during the leadersтАЩ last meeting in early January.[2] Abdi said that he and Shara still disagree on the тАЬpractical details,тАЭ including тАЬthe tools for us to work togetherтАЭ and the тАЬtimeline.тАЭ[3] Abdi is likely referring to the specific mechanisms for SDF integration into the Syrian army. An SDF commander said on February 18 that the SDF and the governing body in northeast Syria agreed to merge their forces into the Syrian Defense Ministry.[4] Abdi has not yet publicly confirmed such an agreement. AbdiтАЩs demand that the SDF integrate as a тАЬblocтАЭ was one of the main sticking points of negotiations in the past two months, and it is unclear if either side has moderated their demands on this issue. Abdi also told The Guardian that the тАЬTurkish interventionтАЭ was hurting negotiations.[5] CTP-ISW has previously noted that Abdi is unlikely to give up the SDFтАШs ability to defend Kurdish areas against active attacks by Turkey and the Turkish-backed Syrian National Army (SNA).[6]
Turkish aircraft struck the SDF along the eastern bank of the Euphrates River on February 21. Turkish aircraft struck SDF positions east of Jarabulus.[7] Turkey has repeatedly struck SDF positions across the Euphrates River from Jarabulus since February 12.[8]
Turkey continued to strike SDF positions near Qara Qozak Bridge on February 21. Turkish aircraft struck several SDF positions near Sarrin, likely to isolate SDF units at the bridgehead west of the Qara Qozak Bridge.[9]
Anti-SDF media claimed that Turkish drones struck an SDF checkpoint near al Kasrat, south of Raqqa, on February 21.[10]
The Turkish Defense Ministry announced on February 21 that it killed 8 тАЬPKKтАЭ fighters in northwestern Syria.[11] Turkey routinely conducts strikes targeting the "PKKтАЭ in northern Iraq and Syria, but it commonly conflates the PKK and the SDF.
I understand the path that led you to these conclusions. Most of the posters here donтАЩt. They are not as well informed.
Excellent write up on the complexities leading up to escalation of war in the region.
https://mwi.westpoint.edu/keeping-the-middle-east-on-edge-why-iran-threatens-to-retaliate-against-israel-and-why-it-has-not-yet-done-so/
https://news.northeastern.edu/2024/04/19/israel-iran-war/
And Lebanon just told Iran that it can take its war with Israel somewhere else.
https://news.northeastern.edu/2024/04/19/israel-iran-war/
Good on Lebanon!
Your meaning, please?
I replied to your comment before you edited it. Would like to hear further input from you.
It's gone. What did they say?
Look at that Phil got a like.
Good for you some idiot clicked your likey button glow in the dopemine hit.
Hey Phil in order for a war to happen the other side needs to give cause.
Manufactured cause could happen, but many people have finally caught onto those kinds of dirty tricks.
Iran has also directly engaged in bombing the shit out of women and Children twice now but again this clod ignores this simple fact.
Never mind technology rendered their attack toothless they tried and their best effort was pretty pathetic.
As has Hezbollah in Lebanon, the Houthis in Yemen and just yesterday Hamas in Israel.
War happens, murder happens, kidnappings happen the other side engages in all this is it to just be ignored and for how long?
You really are a special kind of stupid.
I have had Iranian tech shot at the ship I was riding last August and again in November by the Iran backed Houthis.
Never mind their tech is so bad the actual missile landed in the next time zone we still got painted with Infrared and launched at.
Their pathetic drones got shot down at least five miles out.
Iran arms and funds them.
Iran is directly involved in proxy wars and is threatening all-out war if anyone targets their efforts to build nuclear devices.
Yes, they fight back, sometimes effectively. As when they crushed the Israeli invasion of Lebanon a generation ago. What's happening this time? There's a news blackout, so I imagine the Israeli invasion has stalled out.
In Iraq, Iranian missiles destroyed various nests of anti-Iranian terrorists.
Another excellent essay by Mr. Kunstler this week which cites names of people and entities and money.
I like it, though I have lamented, and continue to lament, the lack of objectivity and facts regarding Palestine in CFN essays. Just think, if Mr. Kunstler lifted the carpet and shone his (still, at his age) formidable journalistic spotlight on the crimes of the Israeli state against Palestinians, and even the several ISRAELIS, military and civilian, which the IDF deliberately killed on OCT 07, to ensure they were not captured by Hamas. I repeat my request for JHK to host Max Blumenthal on a Kunstlercast.
I did not plan to bring the topic up, since EPA is not related to Palestine.
However, since Ben is going to loudly bray about the splinter in Iran's eye, vs the LOG in Israel's, I want to share a real story that the US media, mainstream and alternative, has quietly not reported.
All you CFNers can bet your a$$ that if two Jews or Israelis were gunned down in the US, Drudge and MSN, etc, would be all over it. Isn't that right?
Well, two Israelis were WERE gunned down, in Miami, on Feb 16, according to The Guardian (w..theguardian.com/us-news/2025/feb/17/miami-shooting-israeli-men). Seventeen shots fired at them. The Israelis survived! They took to Facebook to whine about anti-Semitism.
Yet I heard or read nothing, Why? Because the alleged perpetrator, one Mordechai Brafman, 27, is Jewish.
While in custody, Brafman spontaneously told detectives that while he was driving his truck, тАЬhe saw two Palestinians and shot and killed bothтАЭ, arrest documents said.
A lot of people (correctly) point out media bias concerning crime-non-white defendants' race or ethnicity is painted out. Even though statistically black-on-white crime is far more common than white-on-black, wee you know.
That's how it is with the Middle East. Israel is perfect, even as Israelis slaughter tens of thousands of Palestinians, and displace millions, but Iran is the aggressor and threat to peace. according to the media and some here.
Another one to busy covering for the mullahs.
Do they cut you a check or are you just a shite ass licker?
May God bless you with wisdom.
Lugh are you stupid enough to believe Iran is the good guy in all this?
There are no good guys engaged in the Middle East right now everyone over there is doing something bad.
At last you admit Israel is committing atrocities?
Nope they are fighting a war which includes killing people even sometimes people that should not have died but that is the problem with fighting wars good people die along with the badies.
That is how wars are fought or are you just stupid?
To my knowledge Israelis are not kidnapping and then strangling babies.
Nor are they having parties while returning dead babies.
~ The Ill-Conceived Israeli Squat ~
"To my knowledge Israelis are not kidnapping and then strangling babies." ~ Ben
Israelis don't have to if they're bombing and shooting them.
"Nor are they having parties while returning dead babies." ~ Ben
Israel's 'party' is in their apparently much higher baby-kill ratio and big bags of chips on the tax-pimped dime from Uncle Sam.
See what I mean? It's in that style of Israel-Palestine tit-for-tat without end.
But Palestine has a better position and standing, despite the Israel Lobby, its media and other captured US institutions, and perhaps as comments, such as your ill-conceived ones here, would seem to suggest.
Maybe keep your eyes on March 4th., when the parasite State politicians-- maybe cut from a similar cloth to the ones responsible for creating Israel in the first place-- are supposed to meet somewhere nearby (Qatar?) to discuss this catastrophic issue that shouldn't have started in the first place, eighty years ago.
Israel, as a manufactured State construct, is in the wrong neighborhood. We'll see what comes out of that March 4rth. meeting and what they do with the squat that is Israel.
Hey smart guy.
Name a country in the middle east not carved out with little regard for the crazy tribal morons that live there.
Hint look for the straight lines.
I will wait.
Jews are as middle eastern as anything living there today including the Egyptians, Syrians and Jordanians that now call themselves Palestinians as fake and made up a group of people as any other group calling the ME home.
We got another Hamas lover in the group, do we?
While we are on subject of don't belong there is not a Muslim in North America, South America and Europe that belongs, they should all kick rocks back on over to the sand box!
Or does that only apply to dirty JooOOOooooos in the middle east?
Israel has existed in the middle east for thousands of years much longer than Islam and its history is rich with people kicking sand in their faces and eventually losing.
No difference here they are just too damn stubborn.
~ USAided Israel ~
Just a reminder, Ben, that I'm an anarchist. I can't stress that enough.
So the State, such as the State of Israel, is illegitimate-- right off the bat. So any argument for it is pretty much irrelevant. And let's not conflate it with any more 'Israels' than we need to.
If you/we want Israel to be another kind of Israel, a Stateless one, an organic/grassroots, historically-/religiously-appropriate one, say, and something that's not crutched-- 'USAided'-- by coerced tax hostages of another State, or States, and their MICs, oceans away, then we might be onto something. The Palestinians, etc., might even agree.
As for the Middle East and its current status, well, let's just say it's gotten an unfair shake (sheik?) such as by your ostensible state's illegal war in Iraq for but one example, to say nothing of all its other excursions/incursions in and around the area. And it's a lot easier to talk big when one is on the other side of the business end of a gun.
You keep trashing the people in the general area but seem rather blinkered when it comes to your own State's transgressions, at least in that context.
There are plenty of Jews happily and peacefully living their lives around the world like the rest of us...
They need Israel and special treatment like they need a hole in the head.
____
List Of Jewish Anarchists
en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_Jewish_anarchists
____
youtu.be/HK_gM0WFAeU?si=qhOGlt0MjheWVbLv
"Whirlpools whirl
Dragnets drag
Hell is not the fire
Hell is your belief
In yourself as the higher..."
Is Mordecai Bronfman your new hero? Are you related?
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95744459
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95773959
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95776810
Is being a moron your new pass time?
I don't know about the story, nor do I care one way or the other but if he walked up and killed people without cause then he will have a trial and go to jail.
No different that anyone else in 'Murica except all the illegal aliens committing crimes and just being deported.
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95744459
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95773959
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95776810
____
"There are no good guys engaged in the Middle East right now everyone over there is doing something bad." ~ Ben
What about in 1948?
After 75 years they got squatters rights but you should go back to Europe and give your property to the nearest Indian tribe in Canada you are after all nothing but a dirty squatter on stolen Indian land.
There you go again with a red herring.
Canada, it's history, and I and my family and our history are very different from, and irrelevant to, the Israel-Palestine issue we're discussing.
Again, if those Statists and Zionists setting up Israel in 1948 knew then of the problems or potential problems with the area, whether historically or at the time, they were abjectly irresponsible, to put it mildly perhaps.
Even the commentariat over at JHK's old homesite were expressing concern about the unusual increase in immigration into the US during the past four years or so. Getting them back out was part of Trump's election platform. So why would or should the Palestinians feel much different about 1948, onward?
Anyway, and as I've also mentioned, the Israel-Palestine issue appears as a bit of a distraction from America's (et al's) possible energy interests in the region. In that sense, it appears that Israel is being used as a combination panopticon and base-station/foothold. I've already previously posted a link or two on the energy reserves off the coast of Gaza and in and around the area.
Wars are often, if not always, fundamentally about land and resources.
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95744459
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95773959
https://www.kunstler.com/p/funny-money/comment/95776810
We may see kinetic action in Panama. China is not backing off as willingly as we're being told.
Do we really think that China is just going to kowtow to USA demands? Maybe a while ago, but thanks to BidenтАЩs Mob, primarily, China does not fear us at all anymore.
Is there a good war?
No war is "good." I would argue that some war is "necessary." We here in America have an enormous military sized group of people invading our borders. A necessary war would be to eliminate all of these people and send them packing, in defense of our homes and culture. An unnecessary war is like the one in Afghanistan. I don't give a fuck about Afghanistan, Iraq, Gaza, Iran, Yemen, Syria, Germany, Korea, and just about every other nation our army has planted itself.
The only time war is necessary is when it involves protecting and defending ourselves from an aggressive enemy. Most of the time, if not all of the time, the USA seems to be the aggressor.
Would you rather try to stop the constant incursions of other world powers at the border? Or over there? Biden did neither one and we are where we are now. The organization of the millions of illegal immigrants has just started. I hope Trump can send them home without much bloodshed. The Dems just about destroyed American autonomy.
In other words, you don't believe America should exist or any other nation since all are created and maintained by force or the threat thereof.
Putting words in my mouth?
Yes, there is a good war. A Cold War where blustering and bullshit on both sides cancel each other out. Would there ever be hot war if the politicians were silenced?
Just showing you the implications of your words. You say 2+3 and I say 5. You get offended......
It all depends on your perspective.
The winners think it's great, the losers not so much.
As was the case w/ WW2, but first we have to go through Great Depression 2.
WW2 was a good war?
No war is a good war, Tony.
You're a good little guy. I'm glad you've found a friend.
Yup, Jarek...I like all my computer buddies, even you.
LOL!
Jarek, is that you? Why did you change your name?
Because he keeps pissing Jim off who then bans him but he keeps coming back.
Just like Majella who is now busy posting here and there but apparently has learned to tone it down a bit.
Wait, what? Who are you? Where are we? What is this?
Whose wine? What wine?
Where the hell did I dine?
Must have been a dream
I don't believe where I've been
Come on, let's do it again