9 Comments
User's avatar
⭠ Return to thread
rd3's avatar

I'm sure that there are monstrosities in the South, as well, but, in general, Southerners are less likely to tolerate these abominations. Just compare a stroll along the thoroughfares of Charleston, SC or Savannah, GA to a death march through new areas of DC or San Francisco. Columbus, OH might well be the worst. Its a whole contrived Potemkin Village of offensive architecture and fake "neighborhoods." Its a test kitchen for all the bad ideas of late stage mercantilism and greed.

Expand full comment
Te Burt's avatar

I did enjoy Boston architecture, too. That city has a strong Old World vibe that resonated with my soul. Loved living there. (The school system drove me back to the South.) And it's a "walking city." There's something reassuring about "vintage" architecture. They absolutely ruined Copley Square with that monstrous high-rise glass thing - and the windows kept falling out! (Boston is built on what was once a swamp; even today, it's not 100% stable ground.)

Expand full comment
Gracchus's avatar

Years ago a prof told the story of the windows falling out of the John Hancock Tower. If I recall correctly, the building was originally designed to face a different direction. But the developer could not secure all the land parcels needed for the original design.

So they just rotated the building plan a bit, without redesigning it. Boston has significant onshore winds. Which caused wind load on the building different from what it was designed for. So the windows popped out.

Dunno how accurate that story is. It doesn't exactly match what a quick Google search turns up. But it was told by an architecture professor, in Boston. Take it for what it's worth.

Expand full comment
Te Burt's avatar

I never heard why the windows fell out, so nothing surprises! I recall that when it rained, if a heavy truck drove down a street, car alarms would go off because the ground was still unstable! I experienced that several times. Which has nothing to do with architecture styles, of course. I lived in a great old building that had been elite apts. at one time. Marble on the bathroom floors. 11 ft ceilings. HUGE windows. There were even ghosts, for which I can personally vouch! Loved it.

Expand full comment
The Anti-Gnostic's avatar

I remember reading about this as well. Speaking of, has the Millennium Tower in San Francisco stopped very slowly falling?

Expand full comment
Lugh's avatar

The Ministry of Evil above is replicated in Boston's Government Center. Or vice versa. I'm not sure which was built first.

Expand full comment
The Real Mary Rose's avatar

Go figure; the south is more traditional. Southerners are more apt to be really patriotic as well, not fake patriotic as their northern counterparts.

Expand full comment
rd3's avatar
Feb 5Edited

Of course this is a gross generalization, and more true historically, but, Southerners were characterized by their love of kith and kin and their homeplace, while Northerners were characterized by their adherence to the government and empire, and their desire to force this adherence on everyone else.

It's essentially the difference between middle and southern Italians and their love of their towns and small states versus Garibaldi and his ilk. Or, prior to the Highland clearances, the difference between the Highland Scots and the Lowland/England. In comparison between the US and Great Britain, Forrest McDonald said something to the effect of "I see it now. Your south is our north."

Expand full comment
Owain Glyndŵr's avatar

Let's see what they come up with for the Pacific Palisades.

Expand full comment